Authenticity in Marketing Communications: What Happens When You’re Not Authentic?

Graphic illustration of a person's face featuring mouth and tongue.

Table of Contents

  • Ayah
  • June 5, 2024

Brands, like celebrities and politicians, aren’t immune to scandals and social media mistakes. Once a marketing faux pas is committed, it’s like glitter—impossible to hide once it’s out. So, brands have to stay real and transparent. How? Authenticity is key to maintaining your audience’s loyalty, who can quickly change their opinions.

This is a tough job for marketers: they must keep up with new ways to reach people and keep their messages genuine. The tricky part is that marketing itself often plays fast and loose with authenticity. It’s a wild race where brands scramble to look the best, knock down competitors, and sweep any bad reviews under the rug.

This pressure means staffing firms need to be creative and strategic, all while sticking to their core values.


Fake It, Break It: The Cost of Inauthentic Marketing

People are increasingly savvy and can spot inauthenticity from a mile away. While some companies may be tempted to exaggerate claims or paint a rosier picture than reality, the consequences of such strategies can be severe and far-reaching. Here’s a look at what happens when your marketing isn’t authentic.

Read More: From Frustration to Fallout: Why Candidates Are Giving Recruiters the Cold Shoulder


Client Fallout From Inauthentic Marketing

Here are some ways insincere marketing can negatively affect clients:


Mismatched Expectations

Clients may be led to believe your company has access to a higher caliber of candidates or offers superior services than it does. When the reality falls short, clients can feel misled and dissatisfied.


Loss of Trust

Trust is essential in staffing relationships. If clients perceive that they were misled by deceptive marketing claims, it can damage their trust in the staffing agency, leading to a breakdown in the relationship.


Reduced Business Loyalty

Clients who feel deceived are less likely to use the staffing agency’s services again. This can result in a loss of repeat business and potentially harm long-term profitability.


Negative Reputation

Clients who feel deceived might share their negative experiences with others, which can harm the staffing agency’s reputation. This can deter potential clients from engaging with the agency.


Increased Legal Risks

Misleading advertising can result in legal challenges. Clients who believe they have been deceived may pursue legal action that can result in expensive lawsuits and financial penalties.


Candidate Consequences of Inauthentic Marketing

Misleading marketing also has damaging effects on candidates. Here are a few:


Negative Candidate Experience

Disingenuous marketing can set unrealistic expectations about job roles, company culture, or career prospects. When the job or company environment does not match these expectations, it can lead to poor candidate experience.


Decreased Job Satisfaction and Retention

Candidates placed in positions based on misleading marketing may quickly become dissatisfied when the job does not meet their expectations. This can result in lower retention rates and increased turnover, harming both the candidate’s career progression and the client’s operations.


Damage to Professional Reputation

Candidates associated with an agency known for inauthentic marketing may find their professional reputation affected. Employers might be skeptical about the candidates’ qualifications and the credibility of their references, making it harder for them to secure future opportunities.


Missed Opportunities

Talented candidates may avoid working with staffing agencies known for inauthentic marketing, resulting in missed opportunities for both the candidates and potential employers who could benefit from their skills.


The Real Approach to Genuine Marketing Strategies

Presently, Millennials and Gen Z represent a substantial portion of the workforce with approximately 140 million individuals belonging to these age groups. And research shows that they prefer “real and organic” brands rather than “perfect and well-packaged.”¹ This means brand authenticity isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s essential for winning their loyalty.

Authenticity can make or break your brand. Here are some ways to make your marketing and staffing more authentic:


Honesty is still the best policy.

Authenticity in staffing means being honest about how things work, what it costs, and what makes your company special without exaggerating. Be transparent about:

  • Your recruitment process
  • Pricing and fees
  • What truly sets your staffing firms apart


For example, if your firm specializes in tech roles, clearly explain your expertise in that field instead of claiming to be the best in all industries. When you’re upfront about your processes and fees, it builds trust with clients and job seekers. Avoiding big claims helps you stay believable, showing you can deliver what you promise.


Let testimonials tell your story.

When you aim for authenticity in your marketing, you’re prioritizing honesty and transparency. When you share genuine client testimonials and case studies, you’re essentially letting your successes speak for themselves. These testimonials act like word-of-mouth recommendations from real people who have experienced your firm’s services firsthand.

It’s like you’re saying, “This is who we are, and this is what we’ve achieved.” It’s not about flashy ads or empty promises; it’s about demonstrating your track record and building trust with your audience. When potential clients and job seekers see these authentic stories, they’re more likely to believe in your capabilities and feel confident in their decision to work with you.


Share your vision and mission with clarity.

It’s important to highlight your company’s values, mission, and expertise in a clear and straightforward way. Through this approach, you’re showing potential clients and candidates what you stand for and what makes you unique.

Your values might include honesty, fairness, and respect, which are essential to building trust. Your mission statement explains your overall goals and why you do what you do, giving people a sense of purpose behind your work. And when you talk about your expertise, be it in a specific industry or using innovative techniques, it helps demonstrate your credibility and ability to deliver on your commitments.


Own up to any setbacks.

Openly acknowledging mistakes, rather than trying to cover them up, shows integrity and transparency, which are highly valued by clients and candidates. So, take accountability. Say a candidate had a poor experience, apologize sincerely. Outline the steps you’re taking to prevent similar problems going forward. This builds trust that you hold yourself accountable.


Stick to what your company stands for.

When companies feel pressured to change and connect better with their audience, they often try a “reinvention” to increase connection or get more attention. But these changes can sometimes make you feel very different from what it used to be, which can push clients and candidates away even more.

There are many ways to build a strong connection with your clients and candidates without compromising your company’s core values. Just like a company that acts differently online than it does offline can confuse people.

For example, if a company says it cares about diversity and inclusion but keeps passing qualified candidates from underrepresented backgrounds for promotions, it loses trust. This inconsistency hurts its relationships with both current clients and potential hires.

It’s important to stay true to your company’s values in all aspects of engagement, from recruitment to daily interactions. Here are some places where your company should truly show itself:

  • Website: Make sure your brand shines through in the words and images you use. Tell your audience everything they need to know about your values and identity. A clear About Us page, transparent and clear costs and a helpful FAQ section are key starting points.
  • Social media: Every time you talk to your social media followers, be it in public or private messages, make sure it fits with your company values. Remember, things on the internet stick around forever, so even one wrong comment could damage the trust you’ve built with your audience. It only takes one screenshot to ruin your reputation. Keep your interactions positive and helpful, and don’t engage with trolls. One negative interaction with a company representative can be difficult to recover from.


Read More: What Staffing and Recruitment Industry Leaders Should Prioritize in 2023



Don’t settle for superficial interactions—prioritize authenticity to build trust, loyalty, and meaningful relationships with your clients and candidates. At Allied Insight, we’ll work with you to develop a customized authenticity strategy that aligns with your brand values and resonates with your target audience.

Count on us to guide you in shaping an authentic brand journey. Reach out to us today to get started!


1. Meester, Aimee. “Council Post: Authenticity in Marketing: Why Brands Must Lead with “Why.”” Forbes,


Graphic illustration of a person's face featuring mouth and tongue.

Authenticity in Marketing Communications: What Happens When You’re Not Authentic?

A man sitting at a table writing on a piece of paper.

Is Your Staffing Firm Stuck in the Stone Age? Here’s How PPC Ignites Growth

Three-tier pedestal with star, automation chip, and green clock symbolizing staffing industry's blend of temporary work, AI innovations, and top performers.

Staffing Industry Insights: Temporary Work, AI Innovations, and Top Performers